Strunk & White’s book is essentially a concise manual focused on improving writing skills. It’s packed with straightforward rules and examples aimed at making writing more effective. For instance, they advise writers to avoid unnecessary words, to use the active voice instead of the passive, and to choose straightforward over complicated sentence structures. Their approach is almost like a teacher giving clear, specific instructions on how to construct sentences and organize thoughts so that the writing is easy to understand and enjoyable to read. On the other hand, Orwell’s essay takes a broader and more philosophical approach. He doesn’t just talk about how to write well; he discusses why clear and honest writing is crucial, especially in politics. Orwell argues that vague, misleading, or overly complex language can be used to deceive or manipulate readers. He points out how stale metaphors and jargon can make bad writing not only dull but also dangerous, as it can hide real meanings and prevent clear thinking. Orwell’s focus is less on the mechanics of writing and more on the ethics of how language is used in society.
While Strunk & White provide tools for clear communication, Orwell raises awareness about the potential consequences of how these tools are used. In essence, Strunk & White teach us to build with words efficiently and effectively, while Orwell urges us to be mindful of what we are building and why. Both perspectives are crucial in the realm of writing. The clarity and succinctness championed by Strunk & White are important, but Orwell reminds us that clarity should not just be about style but also about honesty and transparency in communication, especially on important issues like politics and social matters. Together, these works offer a comprehensive understanding of not just how to write, but also the significance and impact of our writing in the broader context of society and culture.
Leave a Reply